• Page Views 1240
  • Today, the City of Vancouver submitted its final evidence to the National Energy Board (NEB) in response to Kinder Morgan’s proposed pipeline expansion. The submission includes 12 reports from external experts, many commissioned with support from partners and intervenors, and explores three key themes:

    1. The economic viability of pipeline expansion within a climate constrained world
    2. Risk of an oil spill from the expanded pipeline and increase in tankers
    3. Impacts of an oil spill on Vancouver

    The reports are further validated by an air quality analysis carried out by Metro Vancouver which found that a major oil spill in Vancouver harbour could result in significant air quality and health issues with up to 1 million people being exposed to unsafe acute levels of Benzene and up to 31,000 people being exposed to levels that would result in mild transient health impacts.
    With the insight gathered from the reports, City staff concluded that, despite what Kinder Morgan asserts, the risks and costs of the pipeline proposal outweigh any benefits that Vancouver may experience. This conclusion was based on the following findings:

    * Kinder Morgan’s assessment has fundamental flaws that systematically underestimate the risks to Vancouver
    * The existing pipeline has a history of spills and was approved with no environmental assessment
    * There are significant gaps in preparedness for a major spill.
    – City staff are working to improve systems but many of the issues are outside of our jurisdiction
    * A major oil spill would be a disaster for Vancouver’s environment, economy, health and reputation
    – Even a less than“worse case ” spill would be disastrous

    The Burrard Inlet and Fraser River estuary are some of the world’s most important ecosystems and are among the defining factors identified in a study that valued Vancouver’s brand at $31 billion due to its reputation as a “green, clean and sustainable” city. Consequently, Vancouver’s brand is more likely to be negatively affected by an oil spill than comparable cities and could impair the brand value by up to $3 billion which would require significant investment to help rebuild.

    The NEB process has been flawed in many ways with no opportunities for oral cross-examination and inadequate information sharing throughout. The City and other intervenors, had only two opportunities to question Kinder Morgan’s evidence and of the 1252 questions submitted by the City, at least 40 per cent of the responses given by Kinder Morgan were deemed by the City to be unsatisfactory. Fortunately, the City’s work in partnership with other jurisdictions and with the input of the expertise of global experts in the relevant areas has allowed us to prepare a rigorous, evidence-based final submission to the NEB.

    The City continues to collect the public questions and concerns about the proposal, which is helping to inform the City’s process and ensure that all voices are heard. People are encouraged to join the conversation online at #TalkTankers or fill out an online survey <>, nearly5,000 residents have done so to date – over 80% of respondents oppose the Kinder Morgan pipeline expansion proposal.

    On May 15, Metro Vancouver staff provided their assessment to the GVRD Board. The Board voted in favour of staff’s recommendations, including expressing opposition to the proposed Kinder Morgan expansion project.

    You can read all of the expert reports, which will be uploaded throughout the day, at vancouver.ca/NEBevidence

    Share

    Related Post

    Related Blogpost

    Leave a Reply

    New Posts Recently publish post More

    • 22 September 2018
      14 hours ago No comment

      The Predator (PG)

      Warrior! Once upon a time a famous body builder from Austria got one of his early starring starts in a science fiction laced thriller featuring aliens. To some not having Arnold Schwarzenegger in 20th Century Fox’s The Predator May be pause for concern. Not so. Thanks to a cracking ...

    • 22 September 2018
      16 hours ago No comment

      Health is wealth (and things we tend to ignore)

      We human beings have a tendency to put off everything to the last minute, especially our health. When we don’t feel pain or when we feel we are in tip top shape, we skip a dental or doctor’s appointment just because we feel we don’t have an eed for ...

    • 21 September 2018
      2 days ago No comment

      City of Vancouver names plaza after late Filipino community pillar Mel Tobias

      The city council of Vancouver has approved the naming of a plaza after Mel Tobias, a respected pillar in the Filipino community who passed away last year. The Mel Tobias Plaza is one of 15 civic places that council named after prominent Vancouver residents in a meeting on September ...

    • 20 September 2018
      2 days ago No comment

      Peso at it’s lowest

      Share prices and the local currency ended lower as the government announced the trade deficit widened in July as imports posted their fastest gain in more than two years while exports barely grew. The Philippine Stock Exchange PSEI Index declined as much as 1.3 percent, taking the total loss ...

    • 16 September 2018
      6 days ago No comment

      MOSAIC’s statement on Shen murder case

      Vancouver, BC – In response to calls from media seeking comment about the Shen murder suspect’s immigration status, Olga Stachova, Chief Executive Officer has released the following statement on behalf of MOSAIC (Multilingual Orientation Services Association for Immigrant Communities). As with all Canadians, the thoughts of MOSAIC staff are ...

    %d bloggers like this: