Hearing ordered on discrimination complaint by Filipino workers versus Tim Nortons

  • Page Views 354
  • The respondents are 658380 B.C. Ltd. (“658380”), who was the former franchisee which operated the Tim Hortons in Fernie; and Pierre Joseph Pelletier and Kristin Hovind-Pelletier (together the “Pelletiers”), a husband and wife who are the principals of 658380 B.C. Ltd.

    Filipinoworkers

    The complaint was also brought against Tim Hortons, Inc. (“THI”) and TDL Group Corp. (“TDL”) (collectively the “Tim Hortons Respondents”). According to the Tim Hortons Respondents, TDL is in the business of licensing the right to operate Tim Hortons restaurants in Canada.

    B.C. Human Rights Tribunal member Walter Rilkoff dismissed in a ruling dated November 5, 2015 the application bythe respondents to dismiss the complaint.

    The complaint alleges that the respondents discriminated against the complainant group in their employment contrary to the Human Rights Code because of the complainants’ race, colour, ancestry and place of origin.

    Specifically, the complainant group alleges that its members were denied overtime premiums, given less desirable shifts and threatened with being returned to the Philippines, while this was not the case with workers who were not foreigners.

    “As most Canadians will know, Tim Hortons restaurants are ubiquitous in Canada selling coffee, donuts, soup, sandwiches and other food and beverages,” tribunal  member Rilkoff noted in his decision.

    The respondent franchisee denied that they have discriminated against the complainant group as alleged and say that they allowed banking of overtime and assisted members of the Complainant Group with immigration and other issues.

    The complainants say that the Tim Hortons Respondents, pursuant to their franchise agreement with the Franchisee Group, have broad powers to determine many aspects of the business.

    According to the decision, the Tim Hortons Respondents assisted the franchisee group with access to the Temporary Foreign Worker program and were able to monitor the performance and activities of the Franchisee Group. This included carrying out audits and reviews of the employment practises of a franchisee, including compliance with employment standards and workers compensation legislation.

    The complainants further assert that the Tim Hortons Group has an internal grievance or investigation processwhereby employees of a franchisee can bring a complaint or concern to the attention of the Franchisor.

    The Code does not require that the Tim Hortons Respondents employ the complainants or have actively engaged in discriminatory conduct in order to be found to have violated the Human Rights Code, according to Rilkoff.

    It may be sufficient if a respondent has the ability to interfere with and influence the employment relationship of the franchisee group with its employees and fails to do so, the tribunal member explained.

    THI is a publicly- traded federally-incorporated company. TDL is a Nova Scotia company extra-provincially registered in Alberta and engaged in the business of developing, opening and licensing the rights to operate Tim Hortons restaurants. TDL is said to be an “indirectly but wholly owned subsidiary of the Respondent THI”, Rilkoff noted.
    On April 3, 2014, TDL gave notice of immediate termination of the franchise agreements and of the leases and exercised its right to purchase furniture, fixtures, equipment and signs owned by 658780.

    The action came after it found in an audit that in part, 658380 had failed to comply with the requirements of the work permits for the Temporary Foreign Worker Program, had failed to pay overtime in accordance with the Employment Standards Act, and had failed to comply with TDL’s Temporary Foreign Worker recruitment policy.

    This action was taken some three and one-half months after the present human rights complaint was filed.

    Share

    Leave a Reply

    New Posts Recently publish post More

    • 23 March 2017
      5 hours ago No comment

      Impeachment against Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte belittled

      Pantaleon Alvarez, who is the Speaker of the House of Representatives, expressed confidence the impeachment complaint filed against Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte by the Magdalo party list, represented by Congressman Gary Alejano, will not prosper. Alvarez noted that not only the charges were fabricated and had no evidence to ...

    • 23 March 2017
      12 hours ago No comment

      World Happiness Report: Norway tops list, Canada is 7th, Philippines ranks 72nd

      A new report shows Norway is the happiest country on Earth. Norway jumped to the top slot in the World Happiness Report released on March 20 although prices of oil,  a key part of its economy, are falling. Income in the United States has gone up over the past ...

    • 23 March 2017
      18 hours ago No comment

      Star Magic 25 Grand Celebration in Canada

      Related

    • 22 March 2017
      1 day ago No comment

      Arroyo, Santos & 9 others lose house posts

      HOUSE leaders on Wednesday pushed through with a revamp that punished allies who failed to vote in favor of the Palace-backed death penalty bill, including former President and now Pampanga Rep. Gloria Macapagal Arroyo, who gave up her post as deputy speaker for Central Luzon. House Majority Leader and ...

    • 22 March 2017
      2 days ago No comment

      PH ‘one of worst places’ for human rights – UN special rapporteur

      The unabated killings accompanying the war on drugs have not only made the Philippines “one of the worst places right now outside an armed conflict situation” but also created a “multifold” human rights crisis, a United Nations expert said. In an interview with Bloomberg TV Philippines, Agnes Callamard, special ...

    %d bloggers like this: